Wednesday Surprise Bakery

My in-home bakery specializes in making cookies, cakes, cupcakes, and cake pops with a personal touch. Creating desserts that look good and taste good is my aim.

Cookies, Bars, and Brownies

Chocolate Chip


$8/doz

These soft chocolate chip cookies are a popular cookie choice. ($0.75 each)

Peanut Blossom


$10/doz

Chocolate and peanut butter make these cookies a crowd pleaser! ($1.25 each)

Waffle Cookies


$15/doz

These cookies are soft like a brownie with frosting in each tasty waffle pocket. ($1.50 each)

Peanut Butter Cup


$12/doz

Peanut butter cups nestled inside peanut butter cookies. What a perfect combination! ($1.00 each)

GF Chocolate Chip*


$20/doz

For those with gluten sensitivity, it can be hard to find good homemade chocolate chip cookies. These hit the spot! ($1.75 each)

* See gluten disclaimer in FAQ’s on home page

Double-Decker Brownies ——- $16/doz

Brownies with a chocolate brownie layer, followed by a chocolate chip cookie layer with chocolate candies on top. ($1.50 each)

Mint Chocolate Brownies


$16/doz

Chocolate brownies with a layer of mint, followed by chocolate frosting. ($1.50 each)

Cream Cheese Banana Bars


$15/doz

Choose from vanilla or almond cream cheese frosting on these banana bars.

Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake


$20

See Custom Cakes link for more information sample ideas.

Sugar Cookies

Royal Icing Cookies


varies

Sweet sugar cookies with royal icing. These start at a base price of $20/dozen and go upwards depending upon complexity and number of colors needed to complete the design.

Buttercream Frosted Cookies


$22

These cookies are a good option in the colder months, but don’t do as well in heat and humidity. Choose almond or vanilla buttercream frosting.

Mini Dessert Pizzas


$25/doz

These cookies are soft and delicious. Choose what fruit toppings you’d like. (May have additional charge for fruit requests that are out of season.)

Cookie Gallery

Royal Icing Cookies

Buttercream Frosted Cookies

Special Occasion Cookies and Treats

Cookie platters with a variety of cookies and other treats are popular holiday options.